Sunday, May 19, 2013

Over Diagnosis or Undertreatment of ADHD?

Recently a front page article in the New York Times by Alan Schwartz described a case that caught the attention of millions of readers. He followed the prescription history of stimulant drugs such as Adderall for a promising young college pre-med student who committed suicide after being prescribed stimulant drugs by multiple doctors who never made a valid initial diagnosis of ADHD. This article was followed by another article about a case involving a lawsuit by parents against  Harvard college following their son's suicide after being prescribed stimulants by a nurse practitioner who allegedly had not followed standard approved diagnostic procedures.

Regardless of the merits of these and many similar stories--and the articles are careful to follow a balanced and non-biased view of these events--they raise the issue of whether the term "diagnosis" is being properly applied to ADHD; for since physicians or other authorized health care specialists  presumably must make a diagnosis in order to prescribe these drugs, (unless they are prescribing "wildly"), it is hard to account for the stupendous increase in prescriptions for stimulants over the past ten years. (According to a study in Pediatrics the increase in stimulant drugs for ADHD over the past ten years is more than 49 percent, second only to the increase in contraceptive prescriptions).

While the DSM-IV diagnostic criteria for ADHD have their limitations, there is little evidence to suggest that the criteria are being applied in a very large number of cases where stimulants are being prescribed. The bulk of prescriptions in fact come from primary care or pediatric physicians, not child psychiatrists. ADHD is a complex disorder requiring considerable time for the history, data gathering from parents and teachers, interviewing of the patients and their caretakers, evaluation of possible environmental or medical problems best accounting for the clinical picture and the application of behavioral or psychotherapeutic alternatives to pharmacotherapy. Unfortunately reimbursement policies and the lure of "quick fix" treatments may be responsible for a great number of individuals receiving drugs they do not need or which are being used illicitly. If there is a vast number of


prescriptions for people who have not been carefully diagnosed, what about those who have. The best epidemiology of ADHD shows that only about 2-4 percent of children and adolescents qualify for the diagnosis, not the nine to fourteen percent claimed by less than pristine methods such as telephone interviews in which the patient is never actually interviewed. Of those, who do qualify, perhaps a quarter never get the treatment most appropriate for their age and circumstances. In this sense there are a relatively small number who are getting illicit prescriptions when truly indicated by good medical practice. But clearly, as the New York Times reporting indicates, the most serious issue is the vast number of "shadow" diagnoses and drugs in the hands of many who abuse them seriously enough to die or become psychotic or addicted. a

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

Speaking to Dr Christian best products for cellulite reduction after the surgery has left
me with a furry jawline. I met a mutual acquaintance a couple of weeks.


my web-site; Cellulite Remedies

Anonymous said...

I like what you guys are up too. This sort of clever work and coverage!

Keep up the fantastic works guys I've incorporated you guys to our blogroll.

my blog - meladerm

jhone keat said...

This is a great post ! it was very informative. I look forward in reading more of your work. Also, I made sure to bookmark your website so I can come back later. I enjoyed every moment of reading it.

mariya said...

It is true that while taking cure from any nurse or medical practitioner, we must be 100% sure that he or she is full fledged knowledgeable about adhd diagnosis ethics. All in all, it was an intelligent post to share!

cerebrabraintech said...

great information about ADHD I want to know if running out of Pine Tree Stateds created me do that to the purpose wherever it happened the method therefore I turned to alternative things like exercise, medication etc., however, on on a daily basis i could not get out however required one thing therefore I visited GNC and hunted for ADD alternatives.

Anonymous said...

What's up, his weekend is fastidious for me, aas this point in time i am reading
this impressive informative article here at my residence.


my website: cosmetic dentist in el cajon

Anonymous said...

GSniper ԝаs releasedin 2008and haѕ never been outdated, It has
always bear on it’s assurance tօ get you’re online Marketing sales through the roof.
Google Sniper is a product that has helped lots of
people. You ѡill leаrn everything from vidеo marketing, ppc, banner advertising (media buys), ppv (cpv) and so on.

Feеl fгеe to surf to my weblog Mi40x download